A complicated 4.5 years renders useless the scale of success that starts and ends with a Super Bowl. Will Jimmy Garoppolo continue as the starting quarterback of the Niners in 2021? In the first game between the teams last season, the Rams gave up 156 yards rushing in 44 carries in a 31-10 beatdown on Monday Night Football., It was a cloud of dust, Morris said, adding, Thats a tough day.. All picks and predictions are suggestions only. Not of all of them will be elite with high ceilings, but Levis should come through on high floor soon. That became another theme that ultimately defined his time in red and gold. With a long-term horizon, Id be doing as much as I can to get a top-eight QB, the AFC analytics executive said. There's no arguing that all four landed in the right spots for their specific skill sets and experience. If they try to take away the middle of the field, we throw it outside. They entered with 11 picks, emerged with nine selections, plus a handful of undrafted free agents, one or two of whom usually stand a chance, but probably not with this roster. The 49ers keep winning with Garoppolo, and their offense remains efficient, but the team would carry more potential with a higher-level QB, and Lance provides that upside (without assurances) due to his arm talent and rushing ability. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER. YEAR TEAM G ATT COMP PCT YDS AVG LNG TD INT 1st 1st% 20+ SCK SCKY RATE; 2022: San Francisco 49ers WR Jalen Hurd, third round, Baylor, No. The shit he takes. Yet as Lynch pointed out, suddenly the Niners have to put more of an emphasis on contingency plans for another Garoppolo injury. He graduated from San Jose State University with a BA degree in journalism. 2. Before that, he covered USCs football program and athletic department. 10. 1. Worked off to the side during training camp and waited in vain as the 49ers sought trade partners. 31 overall, 2017: The polar opposite of Thomas. He was a positionless player with raw athletic ability waiting to be molded into something special. The 49ers' Brock Purdy has become a sensation of sorts, as Mr. Get the latest on L.A.'s teams in the daily Sports Report newsletter. They didnt have first- or second-round picks, where seven teams swooped in for offensive tackles. The criticism, however, isnt coming from thin air, and the reason San Francisco wants to upgrade at quarterback was on full display Sunday when Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes and Buffalo Bills QB Josh Allen battled it out in a thrilling AFC divisional-round playoff game. "It was I think a testament to the commitment of our ownership," Lynch said. Tom Brady, Tampa Bay (35-11) vs. L.A. Rams. All rights reserved. When the 49ers drafted Trey Lance with the No. Spent his time with the 49ers on injured reserve with a back injury and an ACL tear. Copyright 2023 Sporting News Holdings Limited. If anything, theyre facing a conundrum and one which wont likely be answered easily. They needed more range and clutch kicking to upgrade from Robbie Gould and got it in Jake Moody. 49ers draft boosts Super Bowl confidence,, Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), First Republic Bank seized, sold to JPMorgan Chase, 49ers draft boosts Super Bowl confidence, quarterback drama looms, Can 49ers win Super Bowl with rookie kicker? Scouting reports | More draft coverage, All 259 picks | Every team's class Your favorite teams, topics, and players all on your favorite mobile devices. Earlier this week, general manager John Lynch once again stuck to his guns defending Garoppolo in an interview with the Eye Test for Two podcast: If he is injury-free, Lynch was asked, is there any doubt in your mind thatJimmy Garoppolois your quarterback when you line up in September?, No, he said. Garoppolo has been the 49ers' starter since 2017 and has led the team to two NFC Championship Games including this season's against the Los Angeles Rams over the last three years. Lance told Lynch after the Niners drafted him, Garoppolo was one of the first people to reach out. Green Bay was case in point with the idea that GM Brian Gutekunst loaded up to help his young QB. ", 2021 NFL draft coverage All 259 picks | Every team's class Naturally, that trade again cast doubt on Garoppolo's future in San Francisco, which reached fever pitch on April 26 when Shanahan bungled what was meant to be a playful interaction with a reporter. But like Montana, Garoppolo has compiled a gaudy win-loss record as the 49ers' quarterback. 5. There's no easy way to look at Garoppolo's career playoff numbers and explain the 4-1 record or the 2-0 mark against a quarterback of Rodgers' caliber. After Young, Stroud, Richardson, Levis and Hooker, nine more quarterbacks were drafted. Their bigger offensive concern is whether Desmond Ridder is ready to be a franchise QB and not having enough supporting weapons after Drake London and Kyle Pitts in the passing game. 6), Patrick Mahomes (No. The phrase when hes healthy has become all too common a portion of the Jimmy Garoppolo conundrum. Of course the 49ers are 7-27 if their QB's have been Hoyer, Beathard and Mullens. It makes my job easy having them around.". A $300-million (minimum) gondola to Dodger Stadium? A look at some of the hits and misses of the 49ers draft picks from 2017 through the present, with the 2023 Draft beginning Thursday night: (Note: First-round draft picks are expected to be contributors hence no 49ers first-round picks such as Nick Bosa will be included as greatest hits. Kiper's draft grades for every team That's ridiculous, including Stetson Bennett going too early (fourth round, Rams) and both Clifford (fifth round, Packers) and Max Duggan (seventh round) being taken at all. 153 overall: McKivitz has been a capable starter when called upon and a valuable plug-and-play reserve when players are injured. Overall, thats not an ideal combination and limits the overall productivity of the offense. Twenty-four hours before, there was Garoppolo, somehow finding a way to beat Aaron Rodgers, with a big assist from the 49ers' special teams, for the second postseason in three years. A year ago, and, perhaps, even a month ago, the 49ers front office felt like they could get two second-round picks for Garoppolo. NFL Nation: Analysis for every pick The San Francisco 49ers defeated the . All betting content is intended for an audience ages 21+. The 49ers 13-10 victory over the Aaron Rodgers-led Packers last night left the reigning MVP's future in doubt. Lance hasnt stayed healthy. There's a perception that Levis suffered an embarrassing freefall in the 2023. Heres where the cloudiness of Garoppolos situation gets murkier, too. McShay's favorite pick for all 32 teams Jimmy G is an average QB, but not a QB who can ultimately win you a SB. Or take the bold decision to trade three first-round draft picks for Trey Lance, a quarterback who faced questionable competition and hadnt started a lot of games at North Dakota State. (UCLAs Dorian Thompson-Robinson had the 49ers interest, and he went early in the fifth round to the Cleveland Browns.). They have a 24-9 record (including playoffs) with him as the starter, while going 5-23 in all other games under Shanahan without him as the starter. The Niners have undoubtedly fared better with Garoppolo than without him. 11 and the Buccaneers at No. Even if San Francisco wanted to trade Garoppolo now, there aren't any obvious landing spots and Garoppolo's value is at a low point following another injury. And Ford is set to cost San Francisco just a shade over $20 million, 11 percent of the teams salary cap in 2021, compared to Garoppolos $26.4 million (14.5 percent). But for all the familiarity among McVay, Shanahan and the key players who rekindled this NFC West rivalry the last five seasons, Garoppolo this time around is something of an X-factor for San Francisco (1-2). Jimmy Garoppolo has a 39-18 record with the 49ers in his career. There was some rather direct about that approach in the methodical filling of needs under Brett Veach and Andy Reid. But like Montana, Garoppolo has compiled a gaudy win-loss record as the 49ers' quarterback. 3 pick. With starting guard David Edwards out because of a concussion, Matthew Stafford will operate behind a line that will feature a fourth different lineup in four games. He joined the Bay Area News Group in 1995, though he delivered the San Jose News growing up in Cupertino and turned pro as a sportswriter with the Cupertino Courier in 1988. Purdy got hurt when an Eagles pass rusher, Hasson Reddick, raced around the 49ers right flank, but he did so by speeding past backup tight end Tyler Kroft, who was not re-signed this year. Unidad Editorial Informacin Deportiva, S.L.U. "Today was probably our best full game we put together, but we've got a long way to go, there's some yardage we left out there and even some points we left out there, so it's a nice thing that guys are still hungry.". Brady has only been a . What message would it send to Garoppolo and the locker room if they were publically calling out Jimmy G for being oft-injured and wanting an upgrade, only to see no plausible solutions presented and being forced to roll with Garoppolo in 2021 instead? "I think the past couple weeks we've been putting together some good games," Garoppolo said following Monday night's win. The New England Patriots and Chicago Bears, two logical landing spots before the draft, selected quarterbacks in the first round. The 49ers improved to 75-67-3 all-time against the Rams, including a 38-33-1 record on the road. 3 pick in this year's draft. Garoppolo has not played a game since and the 49ers made a franchise-altering trade with the Miami Dolphins on March 26, sending the No. to two NFC Championship Games and one Super Bowl appearance over the last three years. Notably, Mistretta covers baseball, basketball, and football. And it will be a challenge Monday night against a team that ranks first in passing defense, third in scoring defense and fourth in rushing defense. Rams receiver Cooper Kupp catches passes, is adept at running after a catch and now has added the jet sweep to his arsenal. NAME GP REC W% CMP ATT PCT YDS AVG YDS/G TD TD% INT INT% SCK SCKY RATE; Jimmy Garoppolo: 57: 39-18.684: 1,104: 1,632: 67.6: 13,599: 8.3: 238.6: 82: 5.0: 42: 2.6: 115: 769: 99.2: Explore. That combined with some of the on-field tumult throughout his 4.5 years in the Bay Area makes it easy to point out the negatives of his tenure. However, the way he handled the Lance situation off the field while continuing to battle adversity on the field to quarterback the team in another NFC championship game while dealing with a shoulder sprain and torn UCL in his thumb that will require offseason surgery was undeniably impressive. 191 overall, 2021: Coming off a Pro Bowl and All-Pro season in his second year, Hufanga plays with a spirituality instilled by his mentor Troy Polamalu. Once more with Principal Rooney feeling NINE quarterbacks. Beathard, third round, Iowa, No. Hes expected to move in as the starting right tackle with McGlinchey departing in free agency. Forget the 49ers creating a paradigm they just created paranoia. Offensive skill accounted more for than half of their 13 total picks. San Francisco 49ers news fromFanSided Daily, SF 49ers fans can round out bobblehead collection with Steve Young, SF 49ers: 3 under-radar second-year players to watch in 2021, Niners Nations Akash Anavarathan pointed out, 3 reasons why SF 49ers wont trade Jimmy Garoppolo in 2021, Yes, Julius Randle Right Now Might Be Better Than Peak Chris Bosh, SF 49ers mock NFL Draft after would-be trade for Deshaun Watson, SF 49ers: Pros, cons behind a Jimmy Garoppolo trade, 49ers NFL Draft: 5 day-two quarterbacks John Lynch should look at. His characteristically bad interception to end the first half against the Vikings in the divisional playoffs started a stretch of six quarters where he attempted only 14 passes. The 49ers will enter 2022 in the conversation as contenders thanks in part to Garoppolo and what he did in the early days of his tenure. That record breaks a team mark Garoppolo previously shared with Montana and Colin Kaepernick, who a decade ago quarterbacked the 49ers to the franchise's sixth NFC title. But the conundrum presented itself later in the interview when Lynch added the following: When hes healthy, [Lynch] said of his quarterback, hes played at a high level. And one can't forget about receiver Brandon Aiyuk, whose only two targets on Monday night resulted in touchdown catches. Jimmy Garoppolo had 2,437 passing yards last season and 14,289 passing yards over his career. Not as physically gifted as Polamalu, it will be interesting to see how much better he can get. They weren't the same without him. "It'd be very hard for me to picture a situation where Jimmy's not here," Shanahan said. 121 overall, 2017: Led the 49ers in preseason rushing as a rookie but was placed on injured reserve with a minor foot injury. But much has happened since Shanahan first said, "I expect Jimmy to be our starter next year," on Nov. 17 of last year. Shanahan helped make Garoppolo successful against the Rams by deploying a punishing rushing attack and a quick-release passing game devoid of drop-backs. With Jimmy: 22-8 Without Jimmy: 6-24 Its not all of those modified stats you'd get with PFF etc. Ex-NFL GM's best picks, hidden gems in 2023 NFL Draft. Being a consistently winning team in the NFL is a difficult goal to achieve, having stability at the quarterback position is also complicated, will the 49ers be willing to take that risk in order to take the step they are missing to get their sixth Vince Lombardi Trophy? But the 49ers knew what they were doing, and Shanahan devised a system to suit Samuel and make him a star. He has 394 receptions for 5,254 yards and 31 touchdowns, and thats only part of his contribution. Garoppolo has not played a game since and the 49ers made a franchise-altering trade with the Miami Dolphins on March 26, sending the No. All Access Digital offer for just 99 cents! So nice he did it twice! Looking back, there have been mixed results and considerable durability issues from that group. 13 overall, 2020: Kinlaw was supposed to help as a pillar of strength inside after the trade of DeForest Buckner but has yet to be healthy enough to do so through two seasons. NAME GP REC W% CMP ATT PCT YDS AVG YDS/G TD TD% INT INT% SCK SCKY RATE; Jimmy Garoppolo: 57: 39-18.684: 1,104: 1,632: 67.6: 13,599: 8.3: 238.6: 82: 5.0: 42: 2.6: 115: 769: 99.2: Explore. After the 49ers, depending on their QB situation, and the Cowboys, in their own division, the Eagles' biggest threat to be dethroned as NFC champions comes from Detroit. Their defensive front picked up a quick-burst pass rusher in Robert Beal Jr. from two-time national champion Georgia, and hell be looking for scraps in a unit led by Nick Bosa, Arik Armstead and Javon Hargrave, this offseasons biggest prize via free agency. And Houston has its need - especially if it chooses to use its premium . That was evident in their first draft in 2017, when they made swung a deal with the Chicago Bears, wound up with two picks among the first 31 and didnt get anywhere near what they hoped for from either defensive tackle Solomon Thomas or linebacker Reuben Foster. Since being acquired in 2017, the 49ers are 34-15 with Garoppolo and 8-28 without him. Regardless, wed love a fourth guy here. 3 overall, 2017: This is a classic case of over-drafting based on character. Perhaps it won't happen until 2022. February 1, 2022 8:00 pm PT. Once again, the 49ers know their defensive machine will only help their offense, regardless of Purdys health, Lances resiliency and Darnolds third tour stop. April 27, 2023 at 9:15 a.m. SANTA CLARA Whatever mistakes coach Kyle Shanahan and general manager John Lynch have made in the NFL Draft, they've been either good enough or fortunate enough . 10. The primary question stems from their quarterback uncertainty. Kiper's draft grades for every team The San Francisco 49ers have an enigmatic situation with quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo. The 49ers needed a big-time young safety and got the ideal potential starter next to Talanoa Hufanga in Ji'Ayir Brown. The guy didnt have an offseason, he didnt have a preseason, I think hes in his second full week of practice, just to put that in perspective for everybody that wants to be Jimmy haters, Morris said. And while some may blame San Francisco for paying that much money on Garoppolo back when the deal was inked in 2018, the reality is thats what his contract currently commands unless the 49ers find a way to back out of it, either via a cut or trade. Joey Mistretta is a sports writer/editor who covers multiple sports. LB Fred Warner, third round, BYU, No. "If they try to take away the run, we throw it. I agree to receive the "Pick Six Newsletter" and marketing communications, updates, special offers (including partner offers), and other information from CBS Sports and the Paramount family of companies. Unless the Niners find themselves in a cap crunch -- they have about $18.3 million in cap room before signing the rookie class, according to OverTheCap -- or have an opportunity to acquire a high-cost player they can't resist, restructuring Garoppolo's contract won't be financially driven. They also were fourth in yards per attempt ith a robust 4.9. First-rounder Paris Johnson Jr. will be a welcome upgrade at offensive tackle soon, but by trading down to stockpile, they missed out on great values right in front of them for their rebuild, starting by letting Houston grab Will Anderson instead at No. Instead they ended up chasing a little lesser talent then they could have, especially on defense. NFL Nation: Analysis for every pick Garoppolo, who has been the 49ers' starter since 2017, has led S.F. LB Reuben Foster, first round, Alabama, No. Robinson became the 11th running back taken in the first round since 2016, before Jahmyr Gibbs (Lions) went four picks later to make it an even dozen. Much later in that draft, they were able to get a franchise cornerstone in the fifth round with the selection of Iowa tight end George Kittle. They also took three wide receivers (Jayden Reed, Dontavyion Wicks, Grant DuBose). Jimmy Garoppolo record without 49ers in his career. SANTA CLARA Whatever mistakes coach Kyle Shanahan and general manager John Lynch have made in the NFL Draft, theyve been either good enough or fortunate enough to make up for them in later rounds. The 49ers needing 2022 Mr. 88 overall, 2021: The Oklahoma transfer starred at Ohio State, but the 49ers quickly determined they had a better player in Mitchell, who was drafted three rounds later. Elijah Mitchell, back in the lineup after missing time with an injury, led the team with 59 rushing yards on just nine carries. RB Trey Sermon, third round, Ohio State, No. Defensively, the 49ers got reinforcements in the draft for first-year coordinator Steve Wilks, with his input seemingly valued as much as scouts. Dear Abby: Am I overreacting to my European daughter-in-law's behavior? However, considering where the 49ers were when he arrived, the trade to acquire Garoppolo and the ensuing years that followed it have to be marked as a success. 2. But also since 2018, he has drafted only two Pro Bowlers, former punter Jake Bailey and somehow, QB Mac Jones. Levis opens up about draft day Why is Frank McCourt really pushing it? Beathard, left, and Jimmy Garoppolo practice at the team's NFL training facility in Santa Clara, Calif., Wednesday, Nov. 1, 2017. If Trey Lance hits the ground running, Garoppolo will earn some credit for that as well. Even if there was a suitor, the Niners would need Garoppolo's approval because of his no-trade clause. Which player has won the most Super Bowls? But during a 11-10 loss to the Denver Broncos, he struggled to find rhythm and became the butt of ridicule for accidentally stepping out of the end zone for a safety. 32 lingering post-draft questions: Will Lions have regrets? Hopefully well get Brock back soon. The 49ers should check their record without him.. Hes been out there throwing and doing everything, general manager John Lynch said. This has become a reality within San Franciscos situation heading into 2021. But in Round 2, with the Lions, Raiders and Rams looming, the Titans saw Levis becoming a value and jumped into No. Guy wins. The Titans got a top offensive lineman in Peter Skoronski instead and the Buccaneers opted not to take a QB at all, with Baker Mayfield serving as the bridge in 2023. 7. His five consecutive wins kickstarted the 49ers rebuild. There a lot of varied immediate opinions on results of the 2023 NFL Draft, just like any NFL Draft. Considering that, the Lions jumping on Gibbs and grabbing do-everything linebacker Jack Campbell a little early to fill their most glaring immediate needs was smart. 1. When considering that, the Falcons made a luxury pick at a position of strength. 33 to take him. Right now, it looks like that mantle belongs to Purdy, not Lance, if healthy. dhi mortgage closing costs, campground jobs for couples colorado,